diff --git "a/ablation_results/ablation_edge_features.json" "b/ablation_results/ablation_edge_features.json" new file mode 100644--- /dev/null +++ "b/ablation_results/ablation_edge_features.json" @@ -0,0 +1,4076 @@ +{ + "config": { + "num_layers": 8, + "embed_dim": 16, + "hidden_dim": 32, + "num_context_pairs": 5, + "training_grid_sizes": [ + 16, + 24, + 32 + ], + "eval_grid_sizes": [ + 16, + 24, + 32, + 48 + ], + "training_epochs": 500, + "matrices_per_epoch": 4, + "batch_size": 16, + "learning_rate": 0.001, + "gmres_restart": 30, + "gmres_max_iters": 300, + "gmres_rtol": 1e-06, + "num_test_matrices": 20, + "test_domains": [ + "diffusion", + "advection" + ], + "seed": 42 + }, + "models": [ + { + "name": "No Preconditioner", + "param_count": 0, + "train_time": 0.0, + "train_history": [], + "eval": { + "diffusion_16": { + "iterations": [ + 103, + 100, + 85, + 95, + 84, + 97, + 96, + 96, + 80, + 97, + 85, + 89, + 84, + 81, + 74, + 98, + 72, + 120, + 86, + 76 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 9.584606234196805e-07, + 9.234403561870108e-07, + 9.558803529569953e-07, + 9.344791226155268e-07, + 9.97968621391448e-07, + 9.160203779788967e-07, + 9.93017100045726e-07, + 9.823414239346508e-07, + 9.52258133174983e-07, + 9.943033363185653e-07, + 9.57124917928445e-07, + 9.928040607335479e-07, + 8.643368014529486e-07, + 9.632440774231303e-07, + 8.508104126547448e-07, + 9.439912526130977e-07, + 9.389506940910133e-07, + 9.379970757267854e-07, + 9.999113073651387e-07, + 9.241789697701034e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 0.5588214160000007, + 0.4068471079999938, + 0.35339173200000573, + 0.39651753100000064, + 0.3456416810000178, + 0.3970073540000101, + 0.39611798999999337, + 0.39757699000000457, + 0.32140859700001556, + 0.40433064900000204, + 0.3519825150000031, + 0.38255119600000853, + 0.3446581629999912, + 0.3297647630000142, + 0.29389114500000346, + 0.40033319899998787, + 0.2851188200000081, + 0.5553870549999829, + 0.35605094400000326, + 0.30094662700000185 + ], + "median_residual": 9.540692430659892e-07, + "convergence_rate": 1.0, + "avg_iterations": 89.9, + "avg_solve_time": 0.37891727375000245 + }, + "diffusion_24": { + "iterations": [ + 146, + 134, + 141, + 166, + 146, + 108, + 122, + 138, + 128, + 154, + 153, + 179, + 139, + 142, + 152, + 138, + 163, + 145, + 131, + 165 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 9.975112422467846e-07, + 9.430335175023294e-07, + 9.800348305126585e-07, + 9.837539067300993e-07, + 9.709669992605576e-07, + 9.629557595149076e-07, + 9.946835748045505e-07, + 9.548259241750444e-07, + 9.928239617222697e-07, + 9.75270154163746e-07, + 9.713621641284656e-07, + 9.885902146039663e-07, + 9.593913994181684e-07, + 9.97015468176968e-07, + 9.602296914678611e-07, + 9.994470700031567e-07, + 9.500662381956869e-07, + 9.515024317749975e-07, + 9.855454082243825e-07, + 9.672524020762465e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 0.6151955390000126, + 0.552104460999999, + 0.5850814310000203, + 0.6883556049999981, + 0.6180034669999941, + 0.4419682019999982, + 0.5171942339999873, + 0.5688671830000089, + 0.532358371999976, + 0.6458656309999924, + 0.6476169360000199, + 0.7598865489999866, + 0.5734963790000052, + 0.5884846969999558, + 0.6412107619999574, + 0.5700835910000137, + 0.6787399799999889, + 0.6099945379999667, + 0.5430140720000054, + 0.6843444069999691 + ], + "median_residual": 9.73316159146106e-07, + "convergence_rate": 1.0, + "avg_iterations": 144.5, + "avg_solve_time": 0.6030933017999928 + }, + "diffusion_32": { + "iterations": [ + 153, + 168, + 222, + 217, + 182, + 170, + 174, + 165, + 171, + 210, + 181, + 182, + 199, + 185, + 225, + 192, + 208, + 202, + 151, + 186 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 9.700379389986334e-07, + 9.78045678778406e-07, + 9.816105946861604e-07, + 9.989882929189238e-07, + 9.879704001419059e-07, + 9.842741637669771e-07, + 9.913743682408936e-07, + 9.918995583908412e-07, + 9.958219048033907e-07, + 9.821704360330432e-07, + 9.54589319520531e-07, + 9.87584296494755e-07, + 9.92629100947134e-07, + 9.977487983510145e-07, + 9.998992427342807e-07, + 9.675720881889735e-07, + 9.755244751705617e-07, + 9.930784991093112e-07, + 9.916111622667512e-07, + 9.885914411339497e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 0.6584394340000017, + 0.7055810950000136, + 0.9412027820000048, + 0.9257492620000107, + 0.7833757779999928, + 0.7150769369999921, + 0.7429505160000076, + 0.6958182070000021, + 0.7227967759999956, + 0.9169389539999884, + 0.7884721699999773, + 0.7848673689999828, + 0.8473192739999718, + 0.7949220479999894, + 0.9595653380000044, + 0.8100031289999947, + 0.8980281839999975, + 0.8606196270000055, + 0.6561297889999764, + 0.7916669299999626 + ], + "median_residual": 9.882809206379278e-07, + "convergence_rate": 1.0, + "avg_iterations": 187.15, + "avg_solve_time": 0.7999761799499936 + }, + "diffusion_48": { + "iterations": [ + 255, + 241, + 295, + 281, + 300, + 246, + 300, + 248, + 229, + 272, + 272, + 264, + 257, + 300, + 276, + 300, + 286, + 212, + 300, + 269 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + false, + true, + false, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + false, + true, + false, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 9.94288254832228e-07, + 9.986333716923991e-07, + 9.921612931878426e-07, + 9.86596849214175e-07, + 1.9495961854664504e-06, + 9.865357725241918e-07, + 1.0619273779031589e-06, + 9.965006347499474e-07, + 9.864301453372254e-07, + 9.94926665703953e-07, + 9.886766005743277e-07, + 9.91889875500176e-07, + 9.88444131735046e-07, + 3.6706965920346498e-06, + 9.908658404615068e-07, + 1.3687631120000048e-06, + 9.979308937485617e-07, + 9.896973028893808e-07, + 9.922278382612478e-07, + 9.972836591345407e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 1.083647467999981, + 1.0448255990000348, + 1.262686269000028, + 1.188811921000024, + 1.300464020999982, + 1.0540181860000075, + 1.3007312369999795, + 1.0600921820000053, + 0.9749950259999878, + 1.1801829369999837, + 1.1771488840000188, + 1.1320273050000083, + 1.092450561000021, + 1.3021393860000217, + 1.1879318910000052, + 1.3007742450000137, + 1.2180372519999878, + 0.9252438359999928, + 1.3178741920000334, + 1.1680961170000046 + ], + "median_residual": 9.93258046546738e-07, + "convergence_rate": 0.8, + "avg_iterations": 270.15, + "avg_solve_time": 1.163608925750006 + }, + "advection_16": { + "iterations": [ + 86, + 79, + 84, + 80, + 113, + 110, + 87, + 89, + 88, + 102, + 85, + 102, + 103, + 99, + 100, + 97, + 72, + 83, + 93, + 106 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 9.186809813945261e-07, + 9.813979852969459e-07, + 9.678747297781037e-07, + 9.969714853060749e-07, + 9.91325161661994e-07, + 9.732221131264755e-07, + 9.036444866216494e-07, + 9.47856123912477e-07, + 9.63375208278539e-07, + 9.903631834269936e-07, + 9.746372053392343e-07, + 9.494616128306828e-07, + 9.594314051856154e-07, + 9.792931870453985e-07, + 9.68720381089639e-07, + 9.579549569838896e-07, + 9.607067639934054e-07, + 9.59091792517129e-07, + 9.470289918369725e-07, + 9.404791864891443e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 0.36460587999999916, + 0.31739479100002654, + 0.34639946200002214, + 0.32615103999995654, + 0.46888253499997745, + 0.4508339299999875, + 0.36414350500001547, + 0.37954425699996364, + 0.37189382999997633, + 0.41330557400004864, + 0.35227057700001296, + 0.4132589820000021, + 0.4192402719999677, + 0.4043622650000316, + 0.40758030399996414, + 0.40059163999995917, + 0.2858006100000239, + 0.34069768400001976, + 0.390646457999992, + 0.43027912599995943 + ], + "median_residual": 9.620409861359722e-07, + "convergence_rate": 1.0, + "avg_iterations": 92.9, + "avg_solve_time": 0.3823941360999953 + }, + "advection_24": { + "iterations": [ + 147, + 143, + 140, + 153, + 136, + 170, + 156, + 133, + 144, + 150, + 160, + 127, + 119, + 173, + 132, + 148, + 136, + 134, + 169, + 127 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 9.452926076888592e-07, + 9.391950250350078e-07, + 9.597838628844996e-07, + 9.96065259097638e-07, + 9.712689820500277e-07, + 9.905013640352204e-07, + 9.579499280581321e-07, + 9.908067127165108e-07, + 9.281750114117093e-07, + 9.609655128770008e-07, + 9.667007745441997e-07, + 9.629228592979995e-07, + 9.929107357220174e-07, + 9.690583331174277e-07, + 9.754311790904946e-07, + 9.627058411458521e-07, + 9.729027145578776e-07, + 9.991854657858405e-07, + 9.893085228738428e-07, + 9.74003061166847e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 0.6229336430000103, + 0.5977181209999571, + 0.5790631969999822, + 0.6465075389999697, + 0.5583965980000016, + 0.7033405640000296, + 0.6534219940000412, + 0.5483094949999554, + 0.6069125939999935, + 0.6451957070000276, + 0.6623006709999686, + 0.529452230000004, + 0.5122552899999846, + 0.7252582810000376, + 0.548253964999958, + 0.6286958879999816, + 0.5600331610000353, + 0.554311617000053, + 0.7042733650000059, + 0.529270576999977 + ], + "median_residual": 9.701636575837277e-07, + "convergence_rate": 1.0, + "avg_iterations": 144.85, + "avg_solve_time": 0.6057952248499987 + }, + "advection_32": { + "iterations": [ + 184, + 197, + 194, + 220, + 189, + 179, + 175, + 204, + 161, + 197, + 136, + 187, + 191, + 159, + 213, + 221, + 178, + 229, + 183, + 162 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 9.87787020060557e-07, + 9.953302287860993e-07, + 9.906541817811467e-07, + 9.832106833009945e-07, + 9.656532325193355e-07, + 9.725682942535078e-07, + 9.730589899217913e-07, + 9.659815016797358e-07, + 9.898464061465342e-07, + 9.7063981878067e-07, + 9.71792161336701e-07, + 9.80985324558958e-07, + 9.911580865876616e-07, + 9.95117497735625e-07, + 9.944842059749404e-07, + 9.824680141589592e-07, + 9.83339722780672e-07, + 9.944155932551103e-07, + 9.938256333032448e-07, + 9.796804297773069e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 0.7904194270000175, + 0.8383344779999788, + 0.8292100290000235, + 0.9447366090000173, + 0.800030602999982, + 0.7787154359999704, + 0.7537811459999944, + 0.8800600299999815, + 0.680259623999973, + 0.8434322239999688, + 0.5671879350000495, + 0.7930037790000029, + 0.812359822000019, + 0.6759750340000323, + 0.9214210559999856, + 0.9395520190000184, + 0.7726926550000144, + 0.9809758719999877, + 0.7904216020000376, + 0.6856909050000013 + ], + "median_residual": 9.832752030408333e-07, + "convergence_rate": 1.0, + "avg_iterations": 187.95, + "avg_solve_time": 0.8039130142500028 + }, + "advection_48": { + "iterations": [ + 244, + 221, + 300, + 300, + 289, + 267, + 242, + 244, + 267, + 300, + 246, + 280, + 251, + 299, + 240, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 277, + 263 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + false, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + false, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + false, + false, + false, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 9.832637292024383e-07, + 9.936908367206594e-07, + 1.0498891509577322e-06, + 9.882612645918999e-07, + 9.858636923071246e-07, + 9.947686702179365e-07, + 9.86128092741493e-07, + 9.929114818288972e-07, + 9.88340878429188e-07, + 1.0212267181923652e-06, + 9.939999650133896e-07, + 9.952526408752819e-07, + 9.977537142537277e-07, + 9.817991953926936e-07, + 9.86353438824682e-07, + 1.2549311894571365e-06, + 1.1650485084834325e-06, + 1.24265536072372e-06, + 9.995528536982157e-07, + 9.864563163745285e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 1.052998104999915, + 0.9364309480000657, + 1.302004944000032, + 1.303541075000112, + 1.2471212929999638, + 1.1509848639999518, + 1.0551853220000567, + 1.047337743000071, + 1.151930006999919, + 1.30203083899994, + 1.051352651000002, + 1.1906562560000111, + 1.0652516889999788, + 1.3022851409999703, + 1.044220733999964, + 1.300057852000009, + 1.301416228999983, + 1.2952630290000116, + 1.180272068000022, + 1.1227801139999656 + ], + "median_residual": 9.938454008670245e-07, + "convergence_rate": 0.75, + "avg_iterations": 271.5, + "avg_solve_time": 1.1701560451499973 + } + } + }, + { + "name": "Jacobi", + "param_count": 0, + "train_time": 0.0, + "train_history": [], + "eval": { + "diffusion_16": { + "iterations": [ + 76, + 68, + 61, + 74, + 64, + 75, + 70, + 71, + 74, + 77, + 69, + 66, + 66, + 57, + 68, + 73, + 64, + 63, + 79, + 70 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 8.991298766537752e-07, + 9.630903191754028e-07, + 9.707958857395704e-07, + 9.858167093625554e-07, + 9.731822998450343e-07, + 9.503337439643532e-07, + 8.176914805538833e-07, + 9.825112097753005e-07, + 8.933041612364978e-07, + 9.655230709882333e-07, + 9.548454593998417e-07, + 9.812779796076067e-07, + 9.796888904042378e-07, + 8.321853956378314e-07, + 9.28473964444858e-07, + 9.321430083045863e-07, + 8.688100382573306e-07, + 9.94480137525994e-07, + 9.049501588008282e-07, + 9.978239300828553e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 0.33166502399998876, + 0.27684306500000844, + 0.2721863669999891, + 0.29905977700002495, + 0.26676788800000395, + 0.29846406299998307, + 0.2783702220000066, + 0.28465297600001804, + 0.29924581000000217, + 0.31309007999999494, + 0.2787273000000141, + 0.2699920579999855, + 0.27035778500001584, + 0.23781845000002022, + 0.27595454099997596, + 0.29113892399999486, + 0.2667149109999798, + 0.2631392620000099, + 0.3211219000000085, + 0.2811639279999838 + ], + "median_residual": 9.589678892876222e-07, + "convergence_rate": 1.0, + "avg_iterations": 69.25, + "avg_solve_time": 0.28382371655000044 + }, + "diffusion_24": { + "iterations": [ + 110, + 109, + 100, + 104, + 110, + 100, + 93, + 96, + 66, + 103, + 109, + 130, + 95, + 99, + 123, + 101, + 117, + 116, + 99, + 106 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 9.512740289634472e-07, + 9.269116576531196e-07, + 9.662850360920785e-07, + 8.662462895452521e-07, + 9.893754273437405e-07, + 9.42843306765183e-07, + 9.872141297566179e-07, + 9.377763572534468e-07, + 9.960303290341785e-07, + 9.612691568438472e-07, + 9.788559888037077e-07, + 9.76926103355078e-07, + 9.39240635895021e-07, + 9.758218984172976e-07, + 9.671939203336027e-07, + 9.88063152471596e-07, + 9.436905061913925e-07, + 9.67556337878406e-07, + 9.850114607443812e-07, + 9.007481722586496e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 0.4531225979999931, + 0.4481037389999756, + 0.41300743499999726, + 0.42301391800003785, + 0.4556071389999943, + 0.416024402000005, + 0.3928226659999723, + 0.40049504500001376, + 0.27014057399998137, + 0.4217008050000004, + 0.44939039599995567, + 0.5389861429999883, + 0.39549054799999794, + 0.4086586320000265, + 0.5218251079999732, + 0.4147217809999688, + 0.49263523600001236, + 0.48621056199999657, + 0.40799173199997085, + 0.42899539300003653 + ], + "median_residual": 9.667394782128406e-07, + "convergence_rate": 1.0, + "avg_iterations": 104.3, + "avg_solve_time": 0.43194719259999487 + }, + "diffusion_32": { + "iterations": [ + 112, + 104, + 117, + 138, + 136, + 110, + 127, + 133, + 115, + 110, + 114, + 147, + 138, + 122, + 138, + 104, + 126, + 118, + 129, + 112 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 9.574160618645344e-07, + 9.676740577637924e-07, + 9.909696425124159e-07, + 9.60021606798343e-07, + 9.678924881910154e-07, + 9.873614100555944e-07, + 9.7349031606503e-07, + 9.90311898116638e-07, + 9.498073987707817e-07, + 9.754425532027315e-07, + 9.919913803406034e-07, + 9.637971827800328e-07, + 9.63395414898962e-07, + 9.826175644246537e-07, + 9.58988691230796e-07, + 9.96088290936373e-07, + 9.932686637447527e-07, + 9.765381542162899e-07, + 9.641162713170646e-07, + 9.99518189951618e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 0.4704508909999845, + 0.4317712949999759, + 0.5007140479999634, + 0.5821261620000087, + 0.5702289339999993, + 0.458544833000019, + 0.539758241999948, + 0.5623288050000497, + 0.48943663399995785, + 0.4587857640000266, + 0.48112307100001317, + 0.6376434999999674, + 0.5818779720000293, + 0.5277262209999662, + 0.5754201969999713, + 0.4319861660000015, + 0.5337723020000453, + 0.511387238999987, + 0.5445413229999758, + 0.47047491199998603 + ], + "median_residual": 9.744664346338807e-07, + "convergence_rate": 1.0, + "avg_iterations": 122.5, + "avg_solve_time": 0.5180049255499938 + }, + "diffusion_48": { + "iterations": [ + 124, + 174, + 169, + 176, + 199, + 188, + 183, + 149, + 150, + 151, + 168, + 166, + 176, + 224, + 162, + 172, + 199, + 134, + 189, + 173 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 9.979399357153713e-07, + 9.884142894288936e-07, + 9.667751236794213e-07, + 9.741226523941205e-07, + 9.976121050120846e-07, + 9.809944801877172e-07, + 9.994620876411723e-07, + 9.852022521019733e-07, + 9.878010624961973e-07, + 9.817836964982405e-07, + 9.53331443266777e-07, + 9.92637579348076e-07, + 9.92124553203001e-07, + 9.90844434071793e-07, + 9.898119800912236e-07, + 9.97896362713758e-07, + 9.801926007098623e-07, + 9.696715875327068e-07, + 9.955310044858942e-07, + 9.915304886355803e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 0.5310844819999829, + 0.7476857880000125, + 0.7141236890000187, + 0.7577209800000446, + 0.8469476300000451, + 0.8023737390000178, + 0.7895238290000179, + 0.6460845649999669, + 0.6510815800000387, + 0.657640348999962, + 0.7084811209999771, + 0.7005624679999869, + 0.7655328489999533, + 0.962903955999991, + 0.6808792859999926, + 0.7347654010000042, + 0.8466169250000348, + 0.5612284200000204, + 0.8035464850000267, + 0.7385248770000317 + ], + "median_residual": 9.891131347600587e-07, + "convergence_rate": 1.0, + "avg_iterations": 171.3, + "avg_solve_time": 0.7323654209500063 + }, + "advection_16": { + "iterations": [ + 76, + 59, + 72, + 70, + 73, + 82, + 73, + 75, + 61, + 76, + 71, + 57, + 69, + 72, + 59, + 71, + 59, + 76, + 64, + 69 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 9.767954813591535e-07, + 9.093108340529047e-07, + 9.780481195953957e-07, + 9.154175386655435e-07, + 8.775257688087206e-07, + 9.62844291591374e-07, + 9.039394291660628e-07, + 9.338504151907932e-07, + 9.380165956887311e-07, + 9.47604485178755e-07, + 9.116522887878912e-07, + 9.478664918129965e-07, + 9.659941526275897e-07, + 9.169219374543433e-07, + 9.890617919611698e-07, + 8.961762638730811e-07, + 8.664037584572067e-07, + 9.686560669536367e-07, + 9.72573881392887e-07, + 8.606953581026462e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 0.305412777000015, + 0.25048367299996244, + 0.28801493899999286, + 0.2812369859999535, + 0.29488628500001823, + 0.33745031000000836, + 0.293509653000001, + 0.30156302000000323, + 0.2620772669999951, + 0.30639921900001355, + 0.28558298100000457, + 0.2383553170000141, + 0.28498127300002807, + 0.29088143799998534, + 0.2537424299999884, + 0.2862984930000039, + 0.2596803700000123, + 0.31625899800002344, + 0.2675920229999633, + 0.27804378499996574 + ], + "median_residual": 9.359335054397621e-07, + "convergence_rate": 1.0, + "avg_iterations": 69.2, + "avg_solve_time": 0.2841225618499976 + }, + "advection_24": { + "iterations": [ + 84, + 117, + 104, + 75, + 94, + 123, + 100, + 89, + 103, + 90, + 122, + 102, + 95, + 100, + 97, + 110, + 84, + 91, + 110, + 104 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 9.616632352050633e-07, + 9.668639167831937e-07, + 9.305951894504644e-07, + 8.888916309778191e-07, + 9.479919756673445e-07, + 9.96578687151972e-07, + 9.556487252941892e-07, + 9.371914855531338e-07, + 9.925620789593393e-07, + 9.137911762842436e-07, + 9.972702597845475e-07, + 9.518096234242681e-07, + 9.697080902746874e-07, + 9.559206040066308e-07, + 9.937510188645287e-07, + 8.636803537436435e-07, + 9.676576973427348e-07, + 9.582622388153016e-07, + 9.419995752779172e-07, + 9.273015301036846e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 0.34906218999998373, + 0.4977010709999945, + 0.4256670579999877, + 0.3006018879999601, + 0.39640176500000734, + 0.5239180990000136, + 0.41012100099999316, + 0.382770599999958, + 0.4230326009999885, + 0.3884544609999807, + 0.5201064889999998, + 0.41960023000001456, + 0.3981173500000068, + 0.4127148719999809, + 0.40208166900004016, + 0.45434739299997773, + 0.3483658779999814, + 0.39017279299997654, + 0.4542215490000103, + 0.4278970909999771 + ], + "median_residual": 9.5578466465041e-07, + "convergence_rate": 1.0, + "avg_iterations": 99.7, + "avg_solve_time": 0.4162678023999916 + }, + "advection_32": { + "iterations": [ + 120, + 132, + 143, + 133, + 114, + 108, + 113, + 116, + 144, + 130, + 110, + 131, + 139, + 98, + 97, + 137, + 117, + 164, + 120, + 120 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 9.446997633232426e-07, + 9.578867641781446e-07, + 9.842062245900552e-07, + 9.66944901439854e-07, + 9.708176126673667e-07, + 9.594525828858364e-07, + 9.739846666856554e-07, + 9.6391353737697e-07, + 9.58961792847576e-07, + 9.925121435516672e-07, + 9.918166436821208e-07, + 9.935841437726002e-07, + 9.62772926852265e-07, + 9.271991597888886e-07, + 9.604966905836326e-07, + 9.79300386179578e-07, + 9.635438421069243e-07, + 9.863625819807374e-07, + 9.7342805460867e-07, + 9.53687876101845e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 0.5262891449999643, + 0.5553754640000079, + 0.6135163900000293, + 0.5616905180000344, + 0.4869930449999629, + 0.4518264669999894, + 0.48025582899998653, + 0.5052034439999602, + 0.6144893609999826, + 0.548151224000037, + 0.4614208770000232, + 0.5526718189999542, + 0.5889852589999691, + 0.4118520480000143, + 0.40786655599998767, + 0.5754590939999957, + 0.5008797299999515, + 0.7067737230000262, + 0.526510490000021, + 0.5283370399999967 + ], + "median_residual": 9.65429219408412e-07, + "convergence_rate": 1.0, + "avg_iterations": 124.3, + "avg_solve_time": 0.5302273761499947 + }, + "advection_48": { + "iterations": [ + 161, + 148, + 209, + 172, + 183, + 195, + 195, + 185, + 213, + 145, + 169, + 196, + 171, + 205, + 184, + 195, + 182, + 155, + 200, + 178 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 9.910098962444633e-07, + 9.976300291263576e-07, + 9.815862886627485e-07, + 9.81368130869518e-07, + 9.909159652769526e-07, + 9.664390419776366e-07, + 9.922851773474192e-07, + 9.894883355125277e-07, + 9.931452320097168e-07, + 9.72705281306057e-07, + 9.850680219880938e-07, + 9.801642305673664e-07, + 9.865785277242163e-07, + 9.947936119888009e-07, + 9.821093107112175e-07, + 9.904010184541687e-07, + 9.783542060173882e-07, + 9.576544275958497e-07, + 9.927428411524944e-07, + 9.902619056676492e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 0.6780081150000115, + 0.6412553559999878, + 0.9108341099999961, + 0.7332599669999809, + 0.7889310470000055, + 0.8334039139999732, + 0.8282814760000292, + 0.794424106000065, + 0.9146062849999907, + 0.6149504549999847, + 0.7143010940000067, + 0.8291173769999887, + 0.7254889640000783, + 0.8777954820000105, + 0.7922736869999198, + 0.8247134040000219, + 0.7880159930000445, + 0.6615338279999605, + 0.8521707769999693, + 0.7734060269999645 + ], + "median_residual": 9.880334316183721e-07, + "convergence_rate": 1.0, + "avg_iterations": 182.05, + "avg_solve_time": 0.7788385731999995 + } + } + }, + { + "name": "GCN (implicit edges)", + "param_count": 11074, + "train_time": 49.600278476, + "train_history": [ + 0.8017464280128479, + 0.7740879058837891, + 0.7571005523204803, + 0.7336179316043854, + 0.7174767851829529, + 0.7006436288356781, + 0.6883619576692581, + 0.6850391328334808, + 0.6774637848138809, + 0.6753245443105698, + 0.66231469810009, + 0.6539888978004456, + 0.6447504460811615, + 0.6365465074777603, + 0.6285886168479919, + 0.6250714063644409, + 0.6164171695709229, + 0.602135106921196, + 0.6079309433698654, + 0.598058819770813, + 0.6012117564678192, + 0.5831139236688614, + 0.5695194453001022, + 0.5688435733318329, + 0.5679749548435211, + 0.5521062910556793, + 0.5518411546945572, + 0.5439649224281311, + 0.5414940565824509, + 0.5242653787136078, + 0.5447282195091248, + 0.5284907966852188, + 0.513802781701088, + 0.5140951424837112, + 0.5088719427585602, + 0.49626895040273666, + 0.49183815717697144, + 0.513474240899086, + 0.48812513053417206, + 0.48528415709733963, + 0.4865953102707863, + 0.47059933096170425, + 0.46071838587522507, + 0.4422759860754013, + 0.4781891107559204, + 0.44398243725299835, + 0.44290539622306824, + 0.4438094273209572, + 0.42873062938451767, + 0.43022065609693527, + 0.42273806780576706, + 0.41221845895051956, + 0.40796464681625366, + 0.4319740980863571, + 0.41087155789136887, + 0.42732005566358566, + 0.4063582196831703, + 0.3997543603181839, + 0.38619042187929153, + 0.38382717221975327, + 0.3851199224591255, + 0.3954078108072281, + 0.40005362033843994, + 0.3697677254676819, + 0.36606765538454056, + 0.3732088729739189, + 0.34680740535259247, + 0.36193571239709854, + 0.3699367940425873, + 0.3617842197418213, + 0.3478522226214409, + 0.34125130623579025, + 0.3307253122329712, + 0.33025743812322617, + 0.3503314256668091, + 0.3194951191544533, + 0.3275052160024643, + 0.3273305520415306, + 0.3254534751176834, + 0.31352151930332184, + 0.3238550126552582, + 0.3239162564277649, + 0.30674291402101517, + 0.31353410333395004, + 0.3061094582080841, + 0.2983952984213829, + 0.30113817006349564, + 0.29124999046325684, + 0.29483742266893387, + 0.27628644555807114, + 0.28283071517944336, + 0.28506655246019363, + 0.27519742399454117, + 0.2913322225213051, + 0.3086937367916107, + 0.28725121170282364, + 0.2855518311262131, + 0.26323268562555313, + 0.26406700164079666, + 0.25877413526177406, + 0.26053495705127716, + 0.2841576337814331, + 0.2754790149629116, + 0.256193183362484, + 0.26356159523129463, + 0.24273842573165894, + 0.23818622902035713, + 0.2379990816116333, + 0.2759765423834324, + 0.22986571490764618, + 0.23144448176026344, + 0.25031328201293945, + 0.25338298827409744, + 0.22881730645895004, + 0.238379567861557, + 0.22267889603972435, + 0.23151837289333344, + 0.23996025323867798, + 0.23094087094068527, + 0.22678541764616966, + 0.2226717807352543, + 0.24524686112999916, + 0.24302871897816658, + 0.22889480739831924, + 0.22056403756141663, + 0.2356964461505413, + 0.24882039055228233, + 0.22999990731477737, + 0.21375174075365067, + 0.21980645135045052, + 0.2188379466533661, + 0.22353192418813705, + 0.22538737207651138, + 0.2312859520316124, + 0.22470301389694214, + 0.2057812511920929, + 0.21117571368813515, + 0.2067726030945778, + 0.21654003113508224, + 0.21419836208224297, + 0.2205326333642006, + 0.21167678013443947, + 0.21281950175762177, + 0.20392052829265594, + 0.20146146789193153, + 0.19972043856978416, + 0.2055766060948372, + 0.19893861562013626, + 0.2037648968398571, + 0.22361861541867256, + 0.1954539343714714, + 0.2073226384818554, + 0.21157852932810783, + 0.1981663517653942, + 0.19071796163916588, + 0.192310880869627, + 0.22324877232313156, + 0.19875842705368996, + 0.19242168590426445, + 0.1978616863489151, + 0.21242226287722588, + 0.215192761272192, + 0.1862076185643673, + 0.1868693083524704, + 0.20591435208916664, + 0.21063698828220367, + 0.191207617521286, + 0.18187366053462029, + 0.19442705065011978, + 0.1926058679819107, + 0.18570009991526604, + 0.2146230936050415, + 0.20207958668470383, + 0.19507098197937012, + 0.19087006151676178, + 0.21124238893389702, + 0.19113196432590485, + 0.18314549326896667, + 0.19623972848057747, + 0.1912565715610981, + 0.1974700577557087, + 0.19167236983776093, + 0.1871488280594349, + 0.1994028352200985, + 0.18842200934886932, + 0.21173334121704102, + 0.19045302271842957, + 0.17339886724948883, + 0.19368242099881172, + 0.19095421209931374, + 0.19197484850883484, + 0.19051945954561234, + 0.2088032402098179, + 0.18264498561620712, + 0.18574395775794983, + 0.1994498260319233, + 0.20403734222054482, + 0.18128223717212677, + 0.1873079612851143, + 0.20591197535395622, + 0.19099495559930801, + 0.19705071300268173, + 0.19998692348599434, + 0.1950991116464138, + 0.17672181129455566, + 0.1683218516409397, + 0.19367370754480362, + 0.19388248398900032, + 0.18417856842279434, + 0.19100042432546616, + 0.18288659304380417, + 0.18652299791574478, + 0.1705886423587799, + 0.187386866658926, + 0.17163771018385887, + 0.1730922907590866, + 0.17353728786110878, + 0.1827964372932911, + 0.16976241394877434, + 0.1803940162062645, + 0.20059671252965927, + 0.18127236887812614, + 0.18088257685303688, + 0.17896552756428719, + 0.166649017482996, + 0.17297938466072083, + 0.1783873587846756, + 0.18713801354169846, + 0.17664219439029694, + 0.1766037754714489, + 0.18457526341080666, + 0.17007429152727127, + 0.16758419945836067, + 0.17317857220768929, + 0.184350173920393, + 0.18477575108408928, + 0.1703508459031582, + 0.18160317465662956, + 0.18213753402233124, + 0.1850147880613804, + 0.18492277711629868, + 0.1924254335463047, + 0.16977718472480774, + 0.17373495548963547, + 0.18410011753439903, + 0.1785675697028637, + 0.18083515018224716, + 0.16858718171715736, + 0.17712019756436348, + 0.16997462138533592, + 0.18656864017248154, + 0.1639387272298336, + 0.17569584771990776, + 0.18380551785230637, + 0.17215901240706444, + 0.18182725086808205, + 0.18047123402357101, + 0.1665385514497757, + 0.16817405447363853, + 0.1645948775112629, + 0.18808826059103012, + 0.17642144858837128, + 0.16414470225572586, + 0.1738520748913288, + 0.17206299304962158, + 0.1698356457054615, + 0.17363818362355232, + 0.1741652898490429, + 0.1761043593287468, + 0.16649910807609558, + 0.16301229596138, + 0.17140939459204674, + 0.17608295753598213, + 0.16403958946466446, + 0.16670481488108635, + 0.17105035856366158, + 0.15618204325437546, + 0.16447434201836586, + 0.16111582145094872, + 0.17484114319086075, + 0.1903178133070469, + 0.15788426622748375, + 0.16986962407827377, + 0.17121965065598488, + 0.19219644740223885, + 0.16835987195372581, + 0.16490060463547707, + 0.16361140459775925, + 0.17740068212151527, + 0.1861875019967556, + 0.21482590958476067, + 0.16493749991059303, + 0.16838963329792023, + 0.165494617074728, + 0.15957456454634666, + 0.18314926698803902, + 0.15914971753954887, + 0.17115901410579681, + 0.16431663930416107, + 0.1926882266998291, + 0.18065255507826805, + 0.17896002531051636, + 0.1793367937207222, + 0.1560976430773735, + 0.1794469952583313, + 0.15693256631493568, + 0.16077705100178719, + 0.17501358315348625, + 0.17033419758081436, + 0.1707865707576275, + 0.16351963579654694, + 0.17290102317929268, + 0.17521187290549278, + 0.16949303448200226, + 0.18436211347579956, + 0.16823206469416618, + 0.16530198231339455, + 0.16731762140989304, + 0.17071731761097908, + 0.17249969393014908, + 0.17170889675617218, + 0.16438789665699005, + 0.15906019136309624, + 0.16164632141590118, + 0.17100007459521294, + 0.15847374126315117, + 0.15285827592015266, + 0.17377754300832748, + 0.16696251928806305, + 0.17306753620505333, + 0.15833885967731476, + 0.17964838072657585, + 0.16076264902949333, + 0.153960719704628, + 0.16671350970864296, + 0.16842037439346313, + 0.15814028307795525, + 0.1672447882592678, + 0.18337062746286392, + 0.16851766407489777, + 0.16944051533937454, + 0.16396208107471466, + 0.169033445417881, + 0.16072352603077888, + 0.1518344059586525, + 0.18292370438575745, + 0.17322611436247826, + 0.1756790652871132, + 0.16740533336997032, + 0.18415291607379913, + 0.21036413311958313, + 0.17689520120620728, + 0.15679118409752846, + 0.15822439268231392, + 0.15547005459666252, + 0.1661752387881279, + 0.15351225435733795, + 0.17817314714193344, + 0.1610054187476635, + 0.15435119345784187, + 0.16884927079081535, + 0.1543167270720005, + 0.17496760934591293, + 0.1693367213010788, + 0.15721246972680092, + 0.15056930109858513, + 0.1608116775751114, + 0.16016879305243492, + 0.16047927737236023, + 0.1678740531206131, + 0.15328162163496017, + 0.16183027997612953, + 0.17748210579156876, + 0.17012427002191544, + 0.17048338800668716, + 0.15853016078472137, + 0.1724351905286312, + 0.16473396122455597, + 0.16663037985563278, + 0.17014339193701744, + 0.17069486528635025, + 0.17454830929636955, + 0.15217379108071327, + 0.1458180509507656, + 0.1594897024333477, + 0.15413876250386238, + 0.15848829969763756, + 0.2002125345170498, + 0.16049659624695778, + 0.1606219746172428, + 0.16671046987175941, + 0.16732746735215187, + 0.15160011127591133, + 0.16066014766693115, + 0.17223312333226204, + 0.14924777299165726, + 0.16588661447167397, + 0.15008534118533134, + 0.1609164960682392, + 0.1502217836678028, + 0.14976317435503006, + 0.152884379029274, + 0.15635575726628304, + 0.15680162608623505, + 0.17272022366523743, + 0.17074725404381752, + 0.1570538878440857, + 0.1481345370411873, + 0.1490715928375721, + 0.17011753097176552, + 0.1777758039534092, + 0.15257058665156364, + 0.15687158703804016, + 0.1474124938249588, + 0.1538393199443817, + 0.17283658683300018, + 0.15104897692799568, + 0.15653205662965775, + 0.15212704613804817, + 0.14923368766903877, + 0.18522533029317856, + 0.1494133025407791, + 0.15606625378131866, + 0.15676052868366241, + 0.1488487683236599, + 0.18008193373680115, + 0.1526220291852951, + 0.15467340126633644, + 0.1506689414381981, + 0.15266890823841095, + 0.15670321136713028, + 0.1446428932249546, + 0.15246696397662163, + 0.15197745338082314, + 0.14749742299318314, + 0.15548276156187057, + 0.14906079322099686, + 0.16350621730089188, + 0.15725291892886162, + 0.149101123213768, + 0.15927387028932571, + 0.15809517353773117, + 0.15532227978110313, + 0.16347520425915718, + 0.1525036320090294, + 0.16414562985301018, + 0.15105198696255684, + 0.15269973874092102, + 0.17152828723192215, + 0.1710229627788067, + 0.15850403532385826, + 0.15468944236636162, + 0.1454131342470646, + 0.14523200318217278, + 0.1636149287223816, + 0.16921498998999596, + 0.16533269360661507, + 0.15121319890022278, + 0.15899499878287315, + 0.1572742871940136, + 0.14531860500574112, + 0.15968263149261475, + 0.16694922000169754, + 0.20383122935891151, + 0.15616777539253235, + 0.1506466642022133, + 0.14665716886520386, + 0.1392662189900875, + 0.15524068102240562, + 0.1694542020559311, + 0.14535317569971085, + 0.1666390374302864, + 0.15036145225167274, + 0.17268968001008034, + 0.15478389337658882, + 0.1456334963440895, + 0.1712627410888672, + 0.15205583721399307, + 0.16010049730539322, + 0.14314210414886475, + 0.15146831050515175, + 0.14367569610476494, + 0.14586077257990837, + 0.16482653841376305, + 0.14481276646256447, + 0.15861548855900764, + 0.1402367651462555, + 0.15341057255864143, + 0.15390418842434883, + 0.14662913233041763, + 0.14210788905620575, + 0.1534016765654087, + 0.1496037393808365, + 0.15929841250181198, + 0.13541142642498016, + 0.1498907096683979, + 0.15094056725502014, + 0.1438113898038864, + 0.15208041667938232, + 0.1536310650408268 + ], + "eval": { + "diffusion_16": { + "iterations": [ + 32, + 35, + 25, + 33, + 29, + 29, + 29, + 29, + 28, + 33, + 30, + 30, + 29, + 29, + 30, + 28, + 28, + 42, + 28, + 26 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 9.427689935867952e-07, + 9.813958459233556e-07, + 7.842542168978435e-07, + 7.939724186544829e-07, + 7.853536833341077e-07, + 9.56651989679314e-07, + 6.300931413622266e-07, + 9.053563972379013e-07, + 9.176935705300243e-07, + 9.711114943691087e-07, + 9.719125475921676e-07, + 9.198059347510016e-07, + 7.804692178788893e-07, + 8.00202853817736e-07, + 7.321830068115741e-07, + 9.109199826140323e-07, + 8.341947459574873e-07, + 9.14302544021922e-07, + 9.758759698906583e-07, + 7.287538688649364e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 0.38956778299998973, + 0.40960400700001287, + 0.28877713399998584, + 0.3902832779999983, + 0.35221006000000443, + 0.34729458300000715, + 0.3592569449999985, + 0.3528093950000084, + 0.33337816799999587, + 0.40047660400000495, + 0.3583938710000041, + 0.3603805219999856, + 0.3453745230000038, + 0.34288217899998585, + 0.3586245460000157, + 0.33624386799999684, + 0.33187226000001147, + 0.4837637990000019, + 0.3268791540000109, + 0.2997694459999991 + ], + "median_residual": 9.081381899259669e-07, + "convergence_rate": 1.0, + "avg_iterations": 30.1, + "avg_solve_time": 0.35839210625000106 + }, + "diffusion_24": { + "iterations": [ + 41, + 41, + 45, + 47, + 40, + 36, + 41, + 39, + 41, + 43, + 47, + 53, + 43, + 46, + 46, + 42, + 49, + 45, + 44, + 48 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 7.23196512536051e-07, + 9.718441516862296e-07, + 9.647500921637705e-07, + 8.774773140520218e-07, + 9.93865417273737e-07, + 9.124744721825489e-07, + 7.782202354293874e-07, + 9.902541892376931e-07, + 8.502957156074535e-07, + 8.257896476983481e-07, + 9.554031780750049e-07, + 8.861692512943538e-07, + 8.948308666535799e-07, + 9.617218997521038e-07, + 8.321529624398756e-07, + 8.916112189877209e-07, + 6.741238208074011e-07, + 8.131792244587394e-07, + 9.784546038885037e-07, + 9.65037760873613e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 0.4752247490000059, + 0.4733448800000133, + 0.5194368770000324, + 0.5446163540000271, + 0.4611497770000028, + 0.41963268900002504, + 0.4721719159999793, + 0.4514795549999917, + 0.48172100700003284, + 0.4990106790000368, + 0.5515008460000104, + 0.6243909159999816, + 0.49506216300000006, + 0.5307616839999696, + 0.5348779109999668, + 0.48332334999997784, + 0.5676971929999581, + 0.5206491430000142, + 0.5090459680000095, + 0.5539626460000022 + ], + "median_residual": 8.932210428206504e-07, + "convergence_rate": 1.0, + "avg_iterations": 43.85, + "avg_solve_time": 0.5084530151500019 + }, + "diffusion_32": { + "iterations": [ + 46, + 50, + 53, + 55, + 52, + 51, + 54, + 51, + 51, + 51, + 53, + 52, + 52, + 50, + 51, + 68, + 58, + 53, + 47, + 56 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 9.452237511205719e-07, + 9.867907386286955e-07, + 9.187304302078612e-07, + 8.050184223165842e-07, + 9.774562028004801e-07, + 9.328319826194867e-07, + 9.539348379809276e-07, + 8.638307412996165e-07, + 9.832939895433616e-07, + 9.540857366587837e-07, + 8.801163712675733e-07, + 9.32812666115399e-07, + 9.119437415577353e-07, + 9.413013387438532e-07, + 9.249909336746288e-07, + 9.646408058200847e-07, + 8.448303055412314e-07, + 8.533859680986846e-07, + 8.576355572172541e-07, + 9.797299897861448e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 0.5530127229999948, + 0.6093841119999865, + 0.6467760120000321, + 0.6726890969999886, + 0.6298286239999698, + 0.6204206159999899, + 0.6593350439999881, + 0.6193527249999988, + 0.6199762809999925, + 0.6178148760000113, + 0.6476899800000524, + 0.6374338169999874, + 0.6349312570000052, + 0.6046946959999673, + 0.6176382250000074, + 0.8274295680000137, + 0.7182406780000292, + 0.6474763769999754, + 0.5633551010000133, + 0.6865420909999784 + ], + "median_residual": 9.328223243674429e-07, + "convergence_rate": 1.0, + "avg_iterations": 52.7, + "avg_solve_time": 0.641701094999999 + }, + "diffusion_48": { + "iterations": [ + 66, + 65, + 70, + 73, + 78, + 78, + 66, + 88, + 86, + 72, + 60, + 63, + 66, + 85, + 89, + 81, + 76, + 60, + 72, + 81 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 9.75463067066663e-07, + 9.769578982305165e-07, + 9.369030381253651e-07, + 9.28107249894946e-07, + 9.922978477483826e-07, + 9.41916446363883e-07, + 9.460536202783864e-07, + 9.6430089286524e-07, + 9.429399764681956e-07, + 9.283220630735651e-07, + 9.151417783568502e-07, + 9.411111573991792e-07, + 9.595550134780896e-07, + 9.844175917729993e-07, + 9.484705732872421e-07, + 9.116225793521646e-07, + 9.080257383566963e-07, + 9.102735711129672e-07, + 9.25211672636815e-07, + 9.381653541751463e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 0.8134022540000387, + 0.800725927999963, + 0.8533478460000197, + 0.8867998570000282, + 0.9507558530000324, + 0.9525723890000108, + 0.8148011680000309, + 1.1004022109999596, + 1.0599377020000134, + 0.8762282089999758, + 0.748325565000016, + 0.7871769140000424, + 0.8123886430000198, + 1.0544690589999846, + 1.1089629629999536, + 0.9944480270000327, + 0.9133489250000366, + 0.7394456809999497, + 0.8827746370000114, + 1.012865669000007 + ], + "median_residual": 9.415138018815311e-07, + "convergence_rate": 1.0, + "avg_iterations": 73.75, + "avg_solve_time": 0.9081589750000063 + }, + "advection_16": { + "iterations": [ + 31, + 27, + 30, + 27, + 36, + 37, + 27, + 29, + 30, + 33, + 28, + 29, + 31, + 36, + 36, + 28, + 26, + 28, + 27, + 30 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 6.360468818410187e-07, + 8.419360524773344e-07, + 7.387319910347201e-07, + 6.665233282633621e-07, + 8.481709437920501e-07, + 9.326533898001307e-07, + 5.48474217613459e-07, + 9.214214353580349e-07, + 8.382473735364084e-07, + 8.261901944290778e-07, + 9.39894900211428e-07, + 7.321722446954576e-07, + 9.550653404473901e-07, + 8.911437499661975e-07, + 9.590641074652966e-07, + 9.130774052177546e-07, + 7.031052027623643e-07, + 6.93078797811303e-07, + 8.129415369616048e-07, + 6.221166215130081e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 0.37472173000003295, + 0.3167597720000117, + 0.3612936060000038, + 0.3166504059999511, + 0.41635417100002314, + 0.4270324990000063, + 0.3151481269999863, + 0.34580799400004025, + 0.36005618100000447, + 0.38992861500003073, + 0.3361126910000394, + 0.3454912540000237, + 0.37045031200000267, + 0.4171746729999768, + 0.4169935550000332, + 0.3319157650000193, + 0.30203300800002353, + 0.3317333019999751, + 0.31606372200002397, + 0.3615431950000243 + ], + "median_residual": 8.322187839827431e-07, + "convergence_rate": 1.0, + "avg_iterations": 30.3, + "avg_solve_time": 0.3576632289000116 + }, + "advection_24": { + "iterations": [ + 45, + 46, + 47, + 44, + 41, + 43, + 51, + 33, + 45, + 48, + 47, + 41, + 38, + 51, + 37, + 54, + 38, + 43, + 44, + 36 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 8.766856612768066e-07, + 8.438312491003094e-07, + 9.05486383064185e-07, + 8.711761782942844e-07, + 8.088097264376421e-07, + 8.839146775393319e-07, + 7.822214063963334e-07, + 8.680725337463621e-07, + 9.885283160531464e-07, + 8.859936828126265e-07, + 9.416528118391923e-07, + 8.742268778557222e-07, + 9.51628614486374e-07, + 9.491697902296803e-07, + 9.542577878671968e-07, + 7.555573734186717e-07, + 8.939371897337511e-07, + 8.997109481391768e-07, + 9.658593284250689e-07, + 8.642169799513601e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 0.5251979889999916, + 0.5415538290000086, + 0.5456545540000093, + 0.5067750649999994, + 0.4712843710000243, + 0.49410590799999454, + 0.5925208499999712, + 0.3878427260000308, + 0.5182091899999932, + 0.5564785469999833, + 0.5458345409999765, + 0.4745484420000139, + 0.440148693000026, + 0.596744813999976, + 0.4329845390000173, + 0.6337902269999631, + 0.43889567899998383, + 0.49411848800002645, + 0.5105401710000024, + 0.42100563299999294 + ], + "median_residual": 8.849541801759792e-07, + "convergence_rate": 1.0, + "avg_iterations": 43.6, + "avg_solve_time": 0.5064117127999992 + }, + "advection_32": { + "iterations": [ + 51, + 52, + 53, + 51, + 53, + 49, + 52, + 58, + 51, + 51, + 47, + 50, + 53, + 53, + 52, + 57, + 54, + 58, + 49, + 51 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 9.426990215216782e-07, + 8.843592742359236e-07, + 8.866058309155451e-07, + 8.361933129152902e-07, + 7.906560736426499e-07, + 9.983708543170635e-07, + 8.718526920567013e-07, + 8.780184765782041e-07, + 9.291677448153757e-07, + 9.246654626774269e-07, + 9.244529702404256e-07, + 9.970499837307854e-07, + 9.502676151658908e-07, + 8.549796434741117e-07, + 7.981338262601829e-07, + 9.55290996350995e-07, + 8.996244446718044e-07, + 9.803570526847127e-07, + 9.304639592113117e-07, + 9.294091933157214e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 0.618902090000006, + 0.6329023739999684, + 0.6473550119999913, + 0.6227123500000289, + 0.6464910550000127, + 0.5962378820000254, + 0.632120298000018, + 0.7187400950000438, + 0.6135612410000135, + 0.6280324470000096, + 0.5779276829999844, + 0.606857787000024, + 0.6515247530000465, + 0.6468962139999803, + 0.631791719999967, + 0.7030724429999964, + 0.6625709929999744, + 0.7228658629999813, + 0.5882395719999636, + 0.614963194999973 + ], + "median_residual": 9.245592164589262e-07, + "convergence_rate": 1.0, + "avg_iterations": 52.25, + "avg_solve_time": 0.6381882533500004 + }, + "advection_48": { + "iterations": [ + 67, + 55, + 62, + 64, + 63, + 55, + 72, + 66, + 69, + 64, + 58, + 84, + 64, + 71, + 57, + 78, + 74, + 64, + 67, + 58 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 9.737851464011656e-07, + 9.147545381173926e-07, + 9.574109789769574e-07, + 9.698715305222463e-07, + 9.679433707238912e-07, + 9.610979434380245e-07, + 9.345737435691686e-07, + 9.705312789010925e-07, + 9.679081909706417e-07, + 9.794204159949424e-07, + 9.185208725065012e-07, + 8.680381293562447e-07, + 9.781168572878365e-07, + 9.637536756546285e-07, + 9.779738753694618e-07, + 9.423091903287733e-07, + 9.624789702028951e-07, + 9.397661606660541e-07, + 9.446655916706083e-07, + 9.551707635631445e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 0.8260970480000651, + 0.6809683999999834, + 0.7734240969999746, + 0.7893937019999839, + 0.7805360440000868, + 0.6700489670000707, + 0.8718121000000565, + 0.8067112720000296, + 0.8409318359999816, + 0.785473144999969, + 0.7145426249999218, + 1.0223218680000628, + 0.7802836790000356, + 0.8601186079999934, + 0.7097207089999529, + 0.9592017520000127, + 0.9064326600000641, + 0.7924088590000338, + 0.8226374289999967, + 0.7197304149999582 + ], + "median_residual": 9.617884568204597e-07, + "convergence_rate": 1.0, + "avg_iterations": 65.6, + "avg_solve_time": 0.8056397607500116 + } + } + }, + { + "name": "MPNN (edge features)", + "param_count": 15426, + "train_time": 49.469068367999995, + "train_history": [ + 0.8068011254072189, + 0.7973593026399612, + 0.7909189462661743, + 0.7799130827188492, + 0.7626174092292786, + 0.7545868009328842, + 0.7450904548168182, + 0.7293437868356705, + 0.7233910858631134, + 0.7107388973236084, + 0.6997377425432205, + 0.6825418174266815, + 0.6616316884756088, + 0.6645226776599884, + 0.6479700803756714, + 0.6285646706819534, + 0.6299549490213394, + 0.6083569377660751, + 0.5821401923894882, + 0.5764900892972946, + 0.5813018083572388, + 0.5433056503534317, + 0.539415180683136, + 0.5029196217656136, + 0.5094099119305611, + 0.4971258193254471, + 0.4774131178855896, + 0.4681897982954979, + 0.4507112354040146, + 0.44541671872138977, + 0.44430869817733765, + 0.44596514850854874, + 0.41992083191871643, + 0.40230534970760345, + 0.3889648988842964, + 0.38969260454177856, + 0.3935866355895996, + 0.3786058574914932, + 0.37338119000196457, + 0.3602287247776985, + 0.3794501945376396, + 0.35479559749364853, + 0.3072756677865982, + 0.34629665315151215, + 0.32636503130197525, + 0.3386731669306755, + 0.30670591443777084, + 0.3187897428870201, + 0.3224058672785759, + 0.3243859261274338, + 0.29498204588890076, + 0.3030894100666046, + 0.2749719023704529, + 0.27451273053884506, + 0.2961796149611473, + 0.2717374935746193, + 0.27297966554760933, + 0.2500893175601959, + 0.25369028374552727, + 0.25412407144904137, + 0.25299328193068504, + 0.23850607872009277, + 0.23871125653386116, + 0.26086699962615967, + 0.25508979707956314, + 0.23640915378928185, + 0.23970119282603264, + 0.23160215839743614, + 0.22430526465177536, + 0.23453041538596153, + 0.2186754047870636, + 0.2142692506313324, + 0.23499591276049614, + 0.23111940175294876, + 0.22700294479727745, + 0.23099711537361145, + 0.2158607356250286, + 0.21556169912219048, + 0.2305433228611946, + 0.23104184120893478, + 0.21602171286940575, + 0.20634157210588455, + 0.2086934559047222, + 0.21173791959881783, + 0.22507129609584808, + 0.21322869509458542, + 0.20592713356018066, + 0.21996663138270378, + 0.20427266508340836, + 0.20856448635458946, + 0.20037419721484184, + 0.20023974403738976, + 0.19784588366746902, + 0.21542778238654137, + 0.2085757963359356, + 0.21470649912953377, + 0.1965947113931179, + 0.21195150911808014, + 0.20170529186725616, + 0.19934622943401337, + 0.1984919086098671, + 0.19933467730879784, + 0.19282837584614754, + 0.18432528153061867, + 0.1884782910346985, + 0.18999206274747849, + 0.20262591168284416, + 0.20631641894578934, + 0.19634897634387016, + 0.18365206941962242, + 0.1881711594760418, + 0.19796128943562508, + 0.1972907818853855, + 0.18245162442326546, + 0.19772085547447205, + 0.1851680539548397, + 0.19042271375656128, + 0.1835068017244339, + 0.19451261684298515, + 0.2161770537495613, + 0.18767019733786583, + 0.19194744527339935, + 0.19481104612350464, + 0.1815659999847412, + 0.18631493672728539, + 0.17882473021745682, + 0.19303429871797562, + 0.1849823035299778, + 0.18683183193206787, + 0.20110290497541428, + 0.17786649242043495, + 0.18199696019291878, + 0.18065666407346725, + 0.1710149049758911, + 0.18326770886778831, + 0.18436983227729797, + 0.1822292096912861, + 0.17263572290539742, + 0.18046505376696587, + 0.1976047083735466, + 0.1882258541882038, + 0.19429975003004074, + 0.17480946704745293, + 0.20545868575572968, + 0.18590964004397392, + 0.17664984241127968, + 0.18597767874598503, + 0.1761275827884674, + 0.21559860557317734, + 0.17693863809108734, + 0.18605658039450645, + 0.17265765368938446, + 0.20881184190511703, + 0.18817755579948425, + 0.1768932230770588, + 0.1736375354230404, + 0.1830005943775177, + 0.18064170703291893, + 0.16763467341661453, + 0.18298504501581192, + 0.1776760369539261, + 0.1674956977367401, + 0.1647120676934719, + 0.17703548446297646, + 0.1673162765800953, + 0.2002972662448883, + 0.1725657880306244, + 0.16582591459155083, + 0.18352097272872925, + 0.17523695901036263, + 0.18607667833566666, + 0.18134794011712074, + 0.17422737181186676, + 0.18765492737293243, + 0.15957734733819962, + 0.18219071254134178, + 0.16628358885645866, + 0.1700429432094097, + 0.19120775163173676, + 0.1747499592602253, + 0.19848361983895302, + 0.1901380978524685, + 0.17156225442886353, + 0.17078551277518272, + 0.16197482496500015, + 0.17088360339403152, + 0.18802179768681526, + 0.16824400797486305, + 0.15985971316695213, + 0.17790282890200615, + 0.19299211353063583, + 0.1663549207150936, + 0.17161159589886665, + 0.1817726269364357, + 0.16751673072576523, + 0.16748446226119995, + 0.1611981764435768, + 0.16971249133348465, + 0.1724628023803234, + 0.17110738158226013, + 0.18348030000925064, + 0.16773787885904312, + 0.15489334240555763, + 0.15978672727942467, + 0.21117062121629715, + 0.17153283581137657, + 0.19983640685677528, + 0.1657162718474865, + 0.1849779225885868, + 0.1620945855975151, + 0.172756128013134, + 0.17040545493364334, + 0.1543421521782875, + 0.17607593908905983, + 0.17011649906635284, + 0.16377748921513557, + 0.16522767022252083, + 0.1704222485423088, + 0.17205801233649254, + 0.17325718700885773, + 0.158842321485281, + 0.17939577251672745, + 0.1601226069033146, + 0.16090605035424232, + 0.16758306324481964, + 0.1875685229897499, + 0.15886278077960014, + 0.16007256507873535, + 0.16282615065574646, + 0.17948606237769127, + 0.1719646193087101, + 0.1622387357056141, + 0.16923124343156815, + 0.15858326107263565, + 0.17581824585795403, + 0.16639665886759758, + 0.17148517444729805, + 0.17108606919646263, + 0.1763456128537655, + 0.17350372672080994, + 0.1907675489783287, + 0.16474540159106255, + 0.17786266654729843, + 0.1875598132610321, + 0.15531371161341667, + 0.1947290599346161, + 0.18265142291784286, + 0.1732894331216812, + 0.16448580473661423, + 0.16482678055763245, + 0.15607502311468124, + 0.1677277609705925, + 0.1617463268339634, + 0.1566486991941929, + 0.16240746900439262, + 0.1830553412437439, + 0.1695285588502884, + 0.1552303209900856, + 0.1491561383008957, + 0.16728510707616806, + 0.16456649079918861, + 0.16893835365772247, + 0.16096613556146622, + 0.16383516415953636, + 0.15310698002576828, + 0.1998179666697979, + 0.16339745372533798, + 0.16793329641222954, + 0.15363497287034988, + 0.1605958677828312, + 0.15855296701192856, + 0.1693490706384182, + 0.15372607856988907, + 0.14595600590109825, + 0.1460687629878521, + 0.16365977376699448, + 0.14472147822380066, + 0.1503211222589016, + 0.16584325954318047, + 0.1553880050778389, + 0.15610775351524353, + 0.15183236077427864, + 0.18852351233363152, + 0.15247996896505356, + 0.17920467630028725, + 0.16027260199189186, + 0.173889622092247, + 0.17147478088736534, + 0.17122719064354897, + 0.15248192474246025, + 0.15929699689149857, + 0.1657254695892334, + 0.1635085791349411, + 0.16164685785770416, + 0.14885709434747696, + 0.14986804500222206, + 0.1533173806965351, + 0.1625882238149643, + 0.15779146179556847, + 0.14994927868247032, + 0.14986322820186615, + 0.15603366121649742, + 0.14342866092920303, + 0.1692059114575386, + 0.15783298388123512, + 0.14630728214979172, + 0.16282515600323677, + 0.16084779426455498, + 0.20445037633180618, + 0.15999077633023262, + 0.15131068974733353, + 0.15453152358531952, + 0.14922603592276573, + 0.17376475781202316, + 0.18550925701856613, + 0.16122744604945183, + 0.1651521511375904, + 0.1616392321884632, + 0.14036523923277855, + 0.15721068531274796, + 0.15952284634113312, + 0.1717841513454914, + 0.15293853729963303, + 0.16150089353322983, + 0.16562655568122864, + 0.1532493568956852, + 0.1751086302101612, + 0.1712983325123787, + 0.1547987051308155, + 0.172120850533247, + 0.16173013299703598, + 0.152803435921669, + 0.16090994328260422, + 0.172974843531847, + 0.14434479922056198, + 0.1480814404785633, + 0.15601474419236183, + 0.1614658273756504, + 0.16011694818735123, + 0.1482943408191204, + 0.17680276557803154, + 0.14417027682065964, + 0.16570653766393661, + 0.1585935838520527, + 0.15854184702038765, + 0.16914406791329384, + 0.15162387862801552, + 0.1653434783220291, + 0.1633848138153553, + 0.1816752888262272, + 0.18386704847216606, + 0.14443976804614067, + 0.150710828602314, + 0.15490533411502838, + 0.1615516059100628, + 0.14967435970902443, + 0.19783412665128708, + 0.1708647757768631, + 0.15115943923592567, + 0.15609270334243774, + 0.1505345106124878, + 0.15005270391702652, + 0.16275545209646225, + 0.14842552691698074, + 0.14059684053063393, + 0.17561593651771545, + 0.15090040490031242, + 0.14353787899017334, + 0.16845567151904106, + 0.1661621816456318, + 0.14883366599678993, + 0.172246765345335, + 0.17110039293766022, + 0.15219221264123917, + 0.156129352748394, + 0.16315074265003204, + 0.14094701781868935, + 0.16312673687934875, + 0.15452183783054352, + 0.14445490390062332, + 0.16382019966840744, + 0.15783316269516945, + 0.15173325315117836, + 0.1614333912730217, + 0.17663642391562462, + 0.17226716876029968, + 0.15970146656036377, + 0.18380263447761536, + 0.1617557890713215, + 0.16455789282917976, + 0.1499939300119877, + 0.15922430530190468, + 0.16871438175439835, + 0.16801217570900917, + 0.16228030249476433, + 0.15179549530148506, + 0.15302369371056557, + 0.1610787957906723, + 0.14736829698085785, + 0.14025591686367989, + 0.15107788145542145, + 0.1600627824664116, + 0.17569692060351372, + 0.14732389897108078, + 0.1518208645284176, + 0.15004954487085342, + 0.14458191022276878, + 0.14423662051558495, + 0.16876270622015, + 0.17525994777679443, + 0.13064000755548477, + 0.14482834935188293, + 0.1661125347018242, + 0.14946774393320084, + 0.1545951198786497, + 0.14505276083946228, + 0.15039416402578354, + 0.16247758641839027, + 0.1536221094429493, + 0.14763106778264046, + 0.1573156900703907, + 0.1722727157175541, + 0.13839886710047722, + 0.149198729544878, + 0.16638823226094246, + 0.16863515228033066, + 0.13420553877949715, + 0.14475905895233154, + 0.16849296540021896, + 0.16704390197992325, + 0.13702552393078804, + 0.15760132670402527, + 0.14799561351537704, + 0.1515924409031868, + 0.1329957526177168, + 0.15622296929359436, + 0.14813287556171417, + 0.16371086984872818, + 0.1551741473376751, + 0.1471995823085308, + 0.13045823946595192, + 0.14527617394924164, + 0.16682802513241768, + 0.15495501086115837, + 0.16818783432245255, + 0.14593243598937988, + 0.15087075531482697, + 0.16479222103953362, + 0.14686766266822815, + 0.16141515225172043, + 0.14341331273317337, + 0.14614470675587654, + 0.1640475019812584, + 0.1466313898563385, + 0.14606130868196487, + 0.1386646293103695, + 0.165225051343441, + 0.13824373483657837, + 0.15356753766536713, + 0.14048036932945251, + 0.14912661537528038, + 0.1641908660531044, + 0.14558755606412888, + 0.14926030114293098, + 0.16600286215543747, + 0.13591081276535988, + 0.14373356848955154, + 0.15724880248308182, + 0.14446822553873062, + 0.15388576313853264, + 0.15080999955534935, + 0.1566593311727047, + 0.13526459783315659, + 0.15697084367275238, + 0.14656758680939674, + 0.14614468067884445, + 0.1348525695502758, + 0.15508607774972916, + 0.15276045352220535, + 0.1480859573930502, + 0.1323071103543043, + 0.1394605040550232, + 0.15267549827694893, + 0.17294468730688095, + 0.1592515893280506, + 0.16382035240530968, + 0.1454394906759262, + 0.19102377071976662, + 0.1872866302728653, + 0.13790420815348625, + 0.17109952121973038, + 0.16974245384335518, + 0.16112910583615303, + 0.1398097164928913, + 0.15911460667848587, + 0.14080427959561348, + 0.16939209029078484, + 0.13642219454050064, + 0.14597326517105103, + 0.15195691213011742 + ], + "eval": { + "diffusion_16": { + "iterations": [ + 30, + 29, + 22, + 25, + 25, + 26, + 25, + 23, + 22, + 26, + 24, + 23, + 23, + 25, + 23, + 25, + 22, + 33, + 25, + 27 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 9.395685210951407e-07, + 9.646846346619503e-07, + 9.256731188505283e-07, + 7.786373337296065e-07, + 6.791839317650046e-07, + 7.741260072383913e-07, + 9.13595361870974e-07, + 9.182378251140823e-07, + 8.685453468510547e-07, + 5.911713506619145e-07, + 8.024946224689426e-07, + 6.771022356389432e-07, + 8.566506324850581e-07, + 6.373612688548692e-07, + 7.373431707352311e-07, + 9.433295852845878e-07, + 7.148671772736104e-07, + 9.403726098467508e-07, + 8.12508471203907e-07, + 7.162588215564089e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 0.30791823799998497, + 0.29393503800000076, + 0.20701178299998446, + 0.24269827699998814, + 0.24362542500000473, + 0.25464474200001064, + 0.2430523940000171, + 0.21891542000000186, + 0.2083001870000203, + 0.256206700000007, + 0.23023436899998728, + 0.21882329700000014, + 0.21902945600001544, + 0.24411846699999273, + 0.21876872600000752, + 0.24277048299998683, + 0.20688470600001096, + 0.32794395499999496, + 0.24131218300001933, + 0.26409056099998907 + ], + "median_residual": 8.075015468364247e-07, + "convergence_rate": 1.0, + "avg_iterations": 25.15, + "avg_solve_time": 0.2445142203500012 + }, + "diffusion_24": { + "iterations": [ + 35, + 28, + 34, + 35, + 32, + 29, + 30, + 28, + 28, + 31, + 31, + 36, + 35, + 32, + 36, + 30, + 34, + 46, + 42, + 34 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 7.780635765269459e-07, + 9.317751973700021e-07, + 8.25020048351616e-07, + 9.853643082039713e-07, + 8.718007819315202e-07, + 7.306057494113997e-07, + 8.874286491972395e-07, + 8.126183036428628e-07, + 7.382174258284716e-07, + 9.766638681503993e-07, + 9.208128085117749e-07, + 9.798290077980679e-07, + 8.929718960948037e-07, + 9.051893899541118e-07, + 8.397134288563817e-07, + 8.859689449887713e-07, + 8.800978040808486e-07, + 9.921756535743636e-07, + 9.273226544745333e-07, + 9.88754527029104e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 0.3458200329999954, + 0.2824542600000086, + 0.33739444200000435, + 0.3442055509999591, + 0.32379395300000624, + 0.294999966999967, + 0.3071766990000242, + 0.28209231400001045, + 0.27970673700002635, + 0.31351205500004653, + 0.31452456700003495, + 0.3553495060000387, + 0.34688215700003866, + 0.32378792800000156, + 0.3510222759999806, + 0.30629857000002403, + 0.3400318660000039, + 0.442566252000006, + 0.4022192410000116, + 0.3338268270000526 + ], + "median_residual": 8.902002726460215e-07, + "convergence_rate": 1.0, + "avg_iterations": 33.3, + "avg_solve_time": 0.33138326005001206 + }, + "diffusion_32": { + "iterations": [ + 33, + 38, + 42, + 46, + 41, + 40, + 32, + 37, + 38, + 37, + 36, + 39, + 39, + 37, + 44, + 40, + 39, + 43, + 37, + 48 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 8.173896650483775e-07, + 8.808332144476029e-07, + 9.87823037724122e-07, + 8.373427508032529e-07, + 8.394829088738064e-07, + 8.432201228581205e-07, + 8.614846484920178e-07, + 9.027451434867715e-07, + 7.974914993131254e-07, + 8.033941652599213e-07, + 7.584114038918883e-07, + 9.855416557811032e-07, + 8.813562496929248e-07, + 8.63636660721752e-07, + 9.890749324746225e-07, + 9.264152593830465e-07, + 9.298895172527433e-07, + 8.826442629561545e-07, + 9.04637352942097e-07, + 9.008357863875396e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 0.3324592959999677, + 0.368369395000002, + 0.402631901999996, + 0.4466149969999833, + 0.4000402009999675, + 0.38786106300000256, + 0.32456125099997735, + 0.36386118300004, + 0.3721919740000317, + 0.363301105000005, + 0.3541245039999694, + 0.37974315499997147, + 0.38100200899998526, + 0.36249244000003955, + 0.43408984900003134, + 0.39192602299999635, + 0.38309975000004215, + 0.4239406159999817, + 0.36450602700000445, + 0.46452784000001657 + ], + "median_residual": 8.810947320702638e-07, + "convergence_rate": 1.0, + "avg_iterations": 39.3, + "avg_solve_time": 0.38506722900000057 + }, + "diffusion_48": { + "iterations": [ + 46, + 51, + 49, + 48, + 54, + 54, + 52, + 63, + 57, + 73, + 40, + 49, + 46, + 59, + 63, + 51, + 49, + 61, + 53, + 49 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 9.308591218353484e-07, + 7.506385389652957e-07, + 9.219029788710124e-07, + 9.949609019584222e-07, + 9.388400133063837e-07, + 9.545544348942885e-07, + 8.745489117232276e-07, + 9.372628976040543e-07, + 8.759844228030638e-07, + 9.64572545970249e-07, + 8.614060766838502e-07, + 8.584089760857001e-07, + 9.372174110342839e-07, + 9.441440795100991e-07, + 9.504404816228243e-07, + 8.536874672882079e-07, + 8.75692951633811e-07, + 9.872470326528883e-07, + 8.846604426153816e-07, + 9.616152649515957e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 0.46226335300002575, + 0.5125587719999771, + 0.48227376099998764, + 0.4739566969999487, + 0.538787818000003, + 0.5419616080000083, + 0.5148004629999718, + 0.6421956969999769, + 0.577132602000006, + 0.7276231109999571, + 0.3923548619999906, + 0.4876000620000127, + 0.451219295000044, + 0.6047468129999629, + 0.6407431769999903, + 0.5046923040000024, + 0.4851866970000174, + 0.6274339390000137, + 0.5360899469999936, + 0.4898744810000153 + ], + "median_residual": 9.340382664348162e-07, + "convergence_rate": 1.0, + "avg_iterations": 53.35, + "avg_solve_time": 0.5346747729499952 + }, + "advection_16": { + "iterations": [ + 24, + 27, + 21, + 27, + 25, + 25, + 26, + 21, + 22, + 23, + 29, + 25, + 48, + 25, + 29, + 27, + 22, + 23, + 22, + 28 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 8.405081040545347e-07, + 8.202866250818482e-07, + 7.718008403221585e-07, + 8.917968449585482e-07, + 6.401337606144384e-07, + 5.36103380565398e-07, + 8.104109667008428e-07, + 7.895289739746499e-07, + 8.775171103066405e-07, + 7.727086663005794e-07, + 8.092418756025532e-07, + 8.665649636125567e-07, + 9.843353947778167e-07, + 8.962725045654802e-07, + 9.37178981260528e-07, + 9.506277715753563e-07, + 8.333163935728243e-07, + 7.520450770321984e-07, + 7.438703465802546e-07, + 8.878306849401185e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 0.23146918700001606, + 0.26712222700001576, + 0.19567220200002566, + 0.26582786199998054, + 0.23919134800001984, + 0.23844536800004335, + 0.25095659200002274, + 0.19218805200000588, + 0.20763915300000235, + 0.2178846799999974, + 0.29853202199996076, + 0.24383393900001238, + 0.46295569000000114, + 0.2422719470000061, + 0.29750883899998826, + 0.26638991100003295, + 0.20601007900000923, + 0.2174024720000034, + 0.20653162499996824, + 0.2797327480000149 + ], + "median_residual": 8.268015093273362e-07, + "convergence_rate": 1.0, + "avg_iterations": 25.95, + "avg_solve_time": 0.25137829715000637 + }, + "advection_24": { + "iterations": [ + 29, + 38, + 27, + 36, + 30, + 35, + 31, + 33, + 39, + 33, + 41, + 30, + 30, + 30, + 27, + 51, + 31, + 28, + 37, + 26 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 8.405255488757975e-07, + 9.97074682375151e-07, + 9.709692244997637e-07, + 9.837203810084457e-07, + 8.509679627717712e-07, + 9.931377403743117e-07, + 9.599925173437188e-07, + 9.942381054233881e-07, + 8.076281227912021e-07, + 8.979958866903963e-07, + 8.919606904495957e-07, + 8.484013198803205e-07, + 9.719415699779947e-07, + 8.828134756760271e-07, + 7.865606587499356e-07, + 8.366460567903342e-07, + 8.761237665084298e-07, + 9.215711104270814e-07, + 7.344764025031613e-07, + 7.56533500599586e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 0.29374661699995386, + 0.3699031140000102, + 0.26962010800002645, + 0.35928630499995506, + 0.30696692100002565, + 0.3449232680000023, + 0.31762714900003175, + 0.3325377669999625, + 0.3768562909999673, + 0.32843211199997313, + 0.39331920900002615, + 0.3068465399999809, + 0.30609073899995565, + 0.3073192119999817, + 0.273007634999999, + 0.5017640240000105, + 0.31341169600000285, + 0.28116971099996135, + 0.36265649199998506, + 0.25169828200000666 + ], + "median_residual": 8.873870830628113e-07, + "convergence_rate": 1.0, + "avg_iterations": 33.1, + "avg_solve_time": 0.3298591595999909 + }, + "advection_32": { + "iterations": [ + 39, + 41, + 39, + 40, + 37, + 39, + 43, + 50, + 37, + 37, + 36, + 39, + 41, + 39, + 39, + 45, + 43, + 46, + 40, + 42 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 9.532113437376374e-07, + 8.758908471402266e-07, + 9.994611868920603e-07, + 8.996203643537225e-07, + 9.152902567569114e-07, + 8.650841903788627e-07, + 8.354890528719347e-07, + 8.543958871225096e-07, + 8.294266651882914e-07, + 8.832477682003004e-07, + 9.791597192070009e-07, + 8.591188982400071e-07, + 9.083480652579473e-07, + 8.338122756662203e-07, + 9.436179332694498e-07, + 9.951052574188852e-07, + 8.394283584247303e-07, + 8.642845574648136e-07, + 8.671094936780492e-07, + 9.439151243240007e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 0.3891586820000157, + 0.404176399999983, + 0.3914770690000182, + 0.388359711000021, + 0.36305652599997984, + 0.38217780799999446, + 0.41737056099998426, + 0.4909898450000014, + 0.3686462549999874, + 0.3674559980000822, + 0.3605521240000371, + 0.385476482999934, + 0.40455113600000914, + 0.3851333050000676, + 0.3831859550000445, + 0.43970437900009074, + 0.4204548169999498, + 0.4476266560000113, + 0.3880053189999444, + 0.40702720499996303 + ], + "median_residual": 8.795693076702635e-07, + "convergence_rate": 1.0, + "avg_iterations": 40.6, + "avg_solve_time": 0.399229311700006 + }, + "advection_48": { + "iterations": [ + 42, + 36, + 56, + 48, + 49, + 51, + 49, + 50, + 50, + 43, + 50, + 50, + 46, + 51, + 49, + 50, + 50, + 53, + 47, + 45 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 8.935878751294071e-07, + 9.918371261116141e-07, + 9.195924339256603e-07, + 9.809934398614575e-07, + 8.668040097504091e-07, + 8.675387371307862e-07, + 8.999459021755772e-07, + 9.819322017608898e-07, + 9.566798613357757e-07, + 9.480838501111181e-07, + 8.572220014675214e-07, + 9.428639827020387e-07, + 8.800118745880715e-07, + 8.749911619779212e-07, + 8.671383139945205e-07, + 9.791938505966473e-07, + 9.101520269497865e-07, + 9.339152934025033e-07, + 9.674049690664004e-07, + 8.841574630480351e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 0.41130466099991736, + 0.35436927099999593, + 0.5605525889999399, + 0.4675144330000194, + 0.478477397000006, + 0.5036538179999752, + 0.4815278030000627, + 0.49247754299994995, + 0.48961579599995275, + 0.417219022999916, + 0.4921810920000098, + 0.49190860500004874, + 0.44984722799995325, + 0.5048483729999589, + 0.4817413939999824, + 0.48869015600007515, + 0.4972364400000515, + 0.5348506129998896, + 0.46319917499999974, + 0.44084899799997856 + ], + "median_residual": 9.148722304377234e-07, + "convergence_rate": 1.0, + "avg_iterations": 48.25, + "avg_solve_time": 0.47510322039998415 + } + } + } + ] +} \ No newline at end of file